How we score
How Sitecomb scores a website
The website quality review checks a website in six areas and gives it a score out of 100.
This page says what we check, how the score is worked out, and what it looks at.
The six areas
Security: Is the front door locked?
HTTPS everywhere · Certificates valid on every server · Who the certificate belongs to · TLS version · Security headers · Cookie flags · Outdated JavaScript libraries · Email anti-spoofing (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) · DNSSEC · Domain expiry date
Privacy & legal: Are the right notices there?
Privacy notice · Cookie notice · Accessibility statement · Irish company details (Irish sites) · UK company details (UK sites) · Checked in 8 languages
Page health: Is it quick, tidy and easy to use?
Speed · Broken links · Image alt text · Page titles · Headings · Sitemap and robots file · Unfilled template text, like {{ name }}
Works on phones: Does it fit in a pocket?
Set up for phones · Fits the screen, no sideways scrolling · Text you can read without zooming · Buttons big enough for a thumb
Contact details: Can people reach you?
Tap-to-call phone number · A contact route that works · Booking · Opening hours · Address
Found online: Can search tools find the facts about you?
AI search crawler rules · Structured data · Open Graph previews · A plain description of the business · llms.txt (optional, not scored)
How the score is worked out
- Each check passes, gives a warning or fails. A pass counts 100, a warning 50 and a fail 0.
- Some checks, like the accessibility and search-engine tests, give their own number from 0 to 100.
- Inside each area, some checks count more than others. Most count once. The ones that matter most to visitors and to safety count two or three times: a site that fits a phone screen, HTTPS, a privacy notice, a contact route that works.
- Each area gets its own score out of 100. The overall score is the average of the area scores, and every area counts the same. An area we couldn't check at all is left out.
- A check that couldn't run is left out. It never counts as a pass or a fail.
- If the website is down, or blocks our checker, it gets no overall score.
Why weigh checks at all? A missing image description and a website with no HTTPS are not the same size of problem.
What “Found online” measures
This area checks whether search tools, including AI search, can read the facts about a business:
- Whether the robots.txt file lets AI search tools in. Blocking tools that only collect training data is never counted against you.
- Structured data, the labels that tell search tools what a page is about.
- Link previews for when the page is shared.
- A plain description of the business near the top of the page.
It measures how easy your website is for these tools to read: the part you control. Whether a tool then recommends you is up to that tool.
What the review looks at
It looks at a website from the outside, the way a visitor and a search engine do:
- Your home page, in a real browser and at a phone's screen size.
- Up to 50 links on that page to your own site, and a few of the notice and contact pages it links to.
- Its security certificate, and public records like its email settings and domain registration.
It reads public pages only. It never logs in, never fills in forms and never tries to break in, so it is not a penetration test. Privacy and legal results show what's missing; they are not legal advice.
How we test our checks
- Every check has automated tests, most of them on a test website built to pass and one built to fail.
- Since September 2026 our rule is that a new check goes live only when it matches our own check by hand on a set of real websites at least 95% of the time.
- Two results from November 2026: the company details check matched our hand check on all 26 websites where it gave an answer, and the certificate checks flagged all 5 test websites with a broken certificate, in both the website quality review and the full quality report.
Think a result is wrong? Tell us at hello@sitecomb.com.